Would you rather is the easiest question format there is, because choosing between two things is much less work than answering something open. That is exactly why it gets past the small talk. Below are 160 of them, sorted by how personal they get, plus the one rule that turns the game into an actual conversation.
The one rule: always ask why
The choice on its own tells you almost nothing. Your partner picking "forgiven quickly" over "understood fully" is a shrug. Your partner explaining why is the entire point of the exercise, and it is usually something you did not know.
Three things make this work in practice:
- Take turns and answer first sometimes. If one person only asks, it stops being a game and becomes an interview.
- Start light and climb. The deep questions land better after twenty minutes of silly ones. Nobody opens up cold.
- Keep a pass rule. Either of you can skip anything without explaining. Knowing you can skip is what makes it safe to answer the rest honestly.
The variant that makes this much better: answer separately, reveal together
There is a flaw in playing out loud. Whoever answers second has already heard the first answer, and it is very hard not to drift towards the one that keeps the peace. You end up with agreement rather than information.
The fix is simple. Both of you write your answer down without showing it, then reveal at the same time. Two things improve immediately: the answers are honest, because neither of you could see the other's first, and you get a second, better question for free, which is whether you correctly guessed what your partner would pick. Knowing someone well is not the same as agreeing with them, and this is the version of the game that tells them apart.
It also works perfectly at a distance, which the out-loud version does not.
This is exactly how Ottermates works. You both answer, and neither of you sees the other's answer until you have both had your say. Free every day, on iPhone and Android.
Get the appWarm-up would you rather questions
Start here. These are low stakes on purpose: they get you both answering quickly and laughing before anything gets personal. Nobody opens up cold.
- Would you rather always be ten minutes early or ten minutes late?
- Would you rather give up chocolate or cheese?
- Would you rather have a week off work or a week of perfect sleep?
- Would you rather be too hot or too cold?
- Would you rather lose your phone or your keys?
- Would you rather eat the same breakfast forever or never eat breakfast again?
- Would you rather have unlimited books or unlimited films?
- Would you rather be able to cook brilliantly or clean instantly?
- Would you rather travel by train or by plane, always?
- Would you rather never queue again or never be stuck in traffic again?
- Would you rather go camping or stay in a hotel?
- Would you rather have a bath every day or a great shower every day?
- Would you rather live somewhere always sunny or somewhere with real seasons?
- Would you rather do the dishes or the laundry for the rest of your life?
- Would you rather have a big garden or a big kitchen?
- Would you rather wake at five every day or go to bed at two every night?
- Would you rather give up podcasts or music?
- Would you rather have a pet that talks or a plant that never dies?
- Would you rather always know the time or always know the weather?
- Would you rather be slightly famous locally or completely anonymous?
- Would you rather have a spotless car or a spotless kitchen?
- Would you rather always get the window seat or always get extra legroom?
- Would you rather have one long holiday or three short breaks?
- Would you rather cook every night or wash up every night?
- Would you rather lose your sense of smell or your sense of direction?
Funny would you rather questions
The answer does not matter here. What matters is watching the other person take a ridiculous premise completely seriously for ten seconds.
- Would you rather fight one horse sized duck or a hundred duck sized horses?
- Would you rather sneeze glitter or cry confetti?
- Would you rather have a permanent cowlick or a permanent milk moustache?
- Would you rather always have to skip instead of walk or always sing instead of talk?
- Would you rather your inner monologue be broadcast for an hour a day or your search history published once?
- Would you rather have hands for feet or feet for hands?
- Would you rather be followed everywhere by a small brass band or a very loud narrator?
- Would you rather only be able to whisper or only be able to shout?
- Would you rather have to high five everyone you meet or hug everyone you meet?
- Would you rather your car horn play a song of my choosing or your ringtone be my voice?
- Would you rather be terrible at every sport or terrible at every board game?
- Would you rather always smell faintly of soup or always be slightly damp?
- Would you rather have to announce yourself in the third person or narrate your own actions?
- Would you rather have a pause button for the day or a rewind button for ten seconds?
- Would you rather be the funniest person in a boring room or the most boring person in a funny room?
- Would you rather everything you cook taste slightly of banana or everything you drink be room temperature?
- Would you rather have to wear formal clothes at home or pyjamas in public?
- Would you rather your pet judged you out loud or your furniture reviewed your posture?
- Would you rather forget names instantly or always call people by the wrong name confidently?
- Would you rather live in a house with no corners or a house with no straight walls?
- Would you rather have to say goodbye by bowing or hello by curtsying?
- Would you rather every photo of you be blurry or every photo be mid sneeze?
- Would you rather have a tail you cannot control or ears that show your mood?
- Would you rather only eat food you can fit in one hand or only drink through a straw?
- Would you rather be mildly haunted or extremely allergic to something you love?
Would you rather questions about the two of you
Now it is about the pair of you specifically. Several of these are quietly useful: they surface preferences people rarely say out loud because nobody ever asks.
- Would you rather we had met earlier or exactly when we did?
- Would you rather I surprised you or asked you first, always?
- Would you rather have a big shared adventure once a year or small ones every month?
- Would you rather be told you are right or be understood?
- Would you rather I remembered every anniversary or noticed every haircut?
- Would you rather we did everything together or kept a few things separate?
- Would you rather have a night out or a night in, if I picked the plan?
- Would you rather be the one who plans or the one who is surprised?
- Would you rather we argued rarely and badly or often and well?
- Would you rather I told you a hard truth immediately or waited for the right moment?
- Would you rather split every chore evenly or each own the ones we hate least?
- Would you rather have separate hobbies or one we do badly together?
- Would you rather I gave you space or came closer when you are upset?
- Would you rather we kept our home tidy or kept our evenings free?
- Would you rather we spent a windfall on a trip or on our home?
- Would you rather be praised in private or in front of other people?
- Would you rather I wrote you a letter or told you out loud?
- Would you rather have a standing weekly date or spontaneous ones?
- Would you rather we ended every day together or started every day together?
- Would you rather I knew what you were thinking or asked you every time?
- Would you rather I learned your favourite meal or your favourite film by heart?
- Would you rather we had a code word for rescue me or for I need you?
- Would you rather share a calendar or keep our own?
- Would you rather I noticed when you are quiet or asked when you are quiet?
- Would you rather we made decisions fast or slept on them?
Deep would you rather questions
Save these for when there is time. A forced choice between two things someone actually values is the fastest honest route into what they believe.
- Would you rather be forgiven quickly or understood fully?
- Would you rather know your future or be able to change your past?
- Would you rather be respected or be liked?
- Would you rather have a life that is comfortable or one that is interesting?
- Would you rather be told the truth kindly or bluntly?
- Would you rather fail at something ambitious or succeed at something easy?
- Would you rather lose an old friendship or a family relationship?
- Would you rather be remembered by many people vaguely or by a few people deeply?
- Would you rather never feel envy or never feel regret?
- Would you rather have more time or more certainty?
- Would you rather your children inherit your strengths or avoid your mistakes?
- Would you rather be needed or be free?
- Would you rather have your work matter or your relationships be easy?
- Would you rather always know when someone is lying or always be believed?
- Would you rather be the person who leaves or the person who stays?
- Would you rather have your worst fear confirmed or never know either way?
- Would you rather be brave once when it counts or steady every ordinary day?
- Would you rather have peace with your family or peace with yourself?
- Would you rather understand why something happened or be able to move on without knowing?
- Would you rather be the reason someone changed or the reason someone stayed the same?
- Would you rather be certain of what you believe or open to changing it?
- Would you rather have your effort recognised or your results?
- Would you rather protect someone from a hard truth or trust them with it?
- Would you rather be the strongest person in your family or the softest?
- Would you rather forgive someone who is not sorry or hold the line?
Would you rather questions about the future
These are the practical ones dressed up as a game. It is much easier to say what you want from the next ten years when it is framed as a choice between two options rather than an open question.
- Would you rather live in a city or somewhere with more sky?
- Would you rather retire early with less or work longer with more?
- Would you rather own a home we like or rent somewhere we love?
- Would you rather travel to twenty countries once or one country twenty times?
- Would you rather have a bigger place or a shorter commute?
- Would you rather live near family or near the sea?
- Would you rather have a predictable life or one we cannot plan?
- Would you rather build something of our own or have secure jobs?
- Would you rather live abroad for a year or take four long holidays?
- Would you rather spend on experiences now or save for later?
- Would you rather have a home full of people or a quiet one?
- Would you rather change careers at forty or keep the one you know?
- Would you rather be busy and stretched or slow and a little bored?
- Would you rather have one big dream or several small ones?
- Would you rather plan the next five years or decide as we go?
- Would you rather have a spare room or a spare month each year?
- Would you rather grow old somewhere familiar or somewhere new?
- Would you rather keep one thing exactly as it is or change everything slowly?
- Would you rather be financially safe or professionally proud?
- Would you rather have a full calendar or an empty one?
Long distance would you rather questions
Written for couples in different places. They need no shared evening and no shared location, which is the point.
- Would you rather have one long call a week or five short ones a day?
- Would you rather send letters or voice notes?
- Would you rather know the exact date we close the distance or keep it open?
- Would you rather visit more often for less time or rarely for longer?
- Would you rather watch something together at the same time or separately and talk after?
- Would you rather have a shared photo album or a shared playlist?
- Would you rather text all day or save it for the evening?
- Would you rather we both moved somewhere new or one of us moved to the other?
- Would you rather have the same time zone or the same weather?
- Would you rather plan the next visit immediately or leave it a while?
- Would you rather hear about your day in detail or the one thing that mattered?
- Would you rather have a standing call time or message whenever?
- Would you rather be sent a photo of something ordinary or something beautiful?
- Would you rather have a countdown or no countdown?
- Would you rather do the same thing apart or different things and compare?
- Would you rather be sent a song or a photo when I think of you?
- Would you rather have a shared list of things to do together or keep them a surprise?
- Would you rather I called when I am tired or waited until I am good company?
- Would you rather we had a ritual for saying goodnight or for saying good morning?
- Would you rather know I miss you or see it when we meet?
After dark would you rather questions
Warmer, and better asked in private than across a dinner table. Skip any of them, no explanation needed.
- Would you rather be told what I like or be asked what you like?
- Would you rather a long slow evening or a spontaneous one?
- Would you rather be complimented on how you look or how you make me feel?
- Would you rather turn the lights down or leave them on?
- Would you rather be kissed goodbye properly or greeted properly?
- Would you rather I told you what I was thinking or showed you?
- Would you rather plan a night away or make an ordinary night feel like one?
- Would you rather dance badly in the kitchen or slow dance properly?
- Would you rather be surprised or be anticipated?
- Would you rather we made a rule about phones after ten or about weekends?
- Would you rather be held or be talked to?
- Would you rather I asked what you need or worked it out?
- Would you rather have a night with no plan or one you designed?
- Would you rather be the one who initiates or the one who is wanted?
- Would you rather we kept one small ritual private or told people about it?
- Would you rather be told a secret or be trusted with one?
- Would you rather have a slow morning together or a late night together?
- Would you rather be surprised with a plan or asked to make one?
- Would you rather I said the compliment out loud or wrote it down?
- Would you rather have one long evening a month or a small moment every day?
Frequently asked questions
How do you play would you rather with your partner?
Take turns, answer honestly, and always ask why. The choice itself is only the doorway; the reason behind it is where you actually learn something. The variant above, writing answers down and revealing them together, stops either of you drifting towards the answer you think the other one wants.
What makes a good would you rather question for couples?
Both options have to be genuinely appealing, or genuinely awful. If one side is obviously correct there is nothing to discuss. The best ones force a trade between two things your partner actually values, like being forgiven quickly or being understood fully.
How many questions should we do in one sitting?
Five good ones with real conversation between them beats fifty rushed. This list is meant to be dipped into over months, not completed in an evening.
Do would you rather questions work for long distance couples?
They work especially well, because a forced choice is easy to answer in a message and needs no shared evening. Answering separately and comparing afterwards is arguably better than playing in person, since neither of you can read the other's face first.
Keep going
If you liked the hypotheticals in this list, the 110 what if questions for couples work the same way: a playful frame that gets you an honest answer without anyone feeling examined. For everything in one place, there are 204 questions for couples sorted by situation.
One question a day, for the two of you. Ottermates picks it, you both answer, and you find out what the other said at the same moment.
Get the app